Cacao vs Coffee in 2025: Why Women Are Swapping Lattes for Ritual Chocolate

A tall glass of cacao and a rose-gold coffee cup steaming against a bright cosmic background with golden, pink, and lavender swirls, styled in an editorial, colourful Stephi vibe.

Introduction: From Buzz to Bliss

For years, my mornings were powered by flat whites. A coffee on Bold Street, earbuds in, inbox open—it felt like culture in a cup. But as my 20s rolled into my 30s, I started to notice the shadow side: cortisol spikes, afternoon crashes, restless sleep.

Then came cacao. Not the sugary powder of childhood, but rich, 100% cacao—velvety, earthy, almost sacred. Blended in a tall glass with unsweetened almond or soy milk, collagen, and hot water, it became more than a drink. It became my ADHD-friendly ritual: quick to make, endlessly grounding, and steady enough to replace my 2pm coffee slump.

And I’m not alone. In 2025, women everywhere are trading the caffeine high for cacao’s slow, sensual glow. This isn’t just another wellness swap—it’s a cultural shift backed by science, hormones, and ritual.


Coffee: The Queen With a Dark Side

The Jitters & Crashes

Coffee’s caffeine blocks adenosine receptors, jolting us awake and flooding dopamine. But for women, that can mean:

  • Cortisol spikes that mess with menstrual cycles and worsen PMS [^1]
  • Magnesium depletion, linked to anxiety, skin flare-ups, and cramps [^2]
  • Sleep disruption, even when consumed six hours before bed [^3]

Hormonal Interference

  • Women metabolize caffeine slower during the luteal phase, making side effects stronger [^4]
  • Coffee raises SHBG (sex hormone-binding globulin), nudging estrogen balance out of sync [^5]

Coffee still shines in longevity research and disease prevention, but for many women, the trade-offs feel harsher every year.

Macro still-life of cacao powder and ceremonial chunks on cream travertine with subtle cosmic sparkles and a small dish of collagen and pink salt.

Cacao: The Gentle Warrior

Meet Theobromine

Cacao’s main stimulant isn’t caffeine—it’s theobromine, a smoother compound that:

  • Improves blood flow & lowers blood pressure [^6]
  • Boosts serotonin and anandamide (the “bliss molecule”) [^7]
  • Provides iron and magnesium—lifelines for women with low ferritin or painful periods [^8]
  • Protects skin from oxidative stress with high flavonoid content [^9]

Ancient Wisdom, Modern Revival

The Mayans and Aztecs drank cacao ceremonially, not as a productivity hack but as medicine and communion. In 2025, that heritage is returning—in cacao ceremonies, women’s circles, and morning kitchen rituals.

Modern still-life of a ceramic cacao cup with a molinillo whisk on cream silk, glowing with a subtle cosmic aura.

Why Women Are Making the Switch

Cycle & Hormone Harmony

Unlike coffee, cacao doesn’t jack up cortisol. It gently supports cycles:

  • Magnesium eases cramps and balances mood [^10]
  • Flavonoids help lower inflammation, easing PMS [^11]
  • Iron restores depleted reserves many women face [^12]

Anxiety & Burnout Recovery

  • A 2025 Nutrients paper linked cacao flavonoids to reduced perceived stress in women under 35 [^13].
  • Its slow energy release makes it kinder to frazzled nervous systems—perfect for women balancing ADHD, PCOS, or burnout recovery.

Community & Ritual

Coffee is transactional. Cacao is relational. From women’s cacao circles to TikTok’s growing #cacaoritual trend, women are reclaiming slowness and connection through this ancient drink.


Science Snapshot

CompoundCoffeeCacaoEffect on Women
Caffeine~95mg/cup~15mg/cupHigh vs gentle stimulation
TheobromineTrace200mg/cupBlood flow, calm focus
Magnesium7mg64mgHormones, cramps, calm
FlavonoidsYesVery highSkin, heart, immunity
Cortisol impact↑↑↔ / ↓Stress & hormone balance

Editorial photo of a woman journaling at golden hour with a tall glass of steaming cacao, soft cosmic swirls in the steam and cozy boho textures.

My ADHD-Friendly Cacao Ritual

Here’s how I drink cacao almost every day:

  • 2–3 teaspoons of 100% natural cacao
  • 1/3 unsweetened almond or soy milk + 2/3 hot water
  • 1–2 spoonfuls each of type I & III collagen and type II collagen
  • Whisked into a tall glass (because mugs never feel big enough)

It’s quick, no-fuss, and doubles as my biohacking stack: cacao’s flavonoids + collagen’s peptides = glowing skin, stronger joints, calmer energy.

Sometimes I’ll stir in cinnamon or pink salt (I add Himalayan salt to my water daily). It’s savoury, not sweet—no sugar, no syrups.

Luke even noticed before I did: “You’re calmer, less wired, but still switched on.” That’s when I knew cacao wasn’t just a phase.


How to Start Your Own Cacao Ritual

  1. Choose ceremonial-grade cacao (organic, ethical, unprocessed).
  2. Heat, don’t boil: whisk cacao into hot water/milk until frothy.
  3. Add your magic: cinnamon, maca, rose, or collagen.
  4. Create intention: light a candle, journal, breathe before sipping.

 Stephi tip: I sip cacao while editing reels or writing—it’s my dopamine anchor on ADHD days.

Sunlit breakfast scene with a tall glass of cacao, collagen in a small dish, and soft pastel aura colours for a bright, energising vibe.

How to Transition From Coffee to Cacao

  • Week 1: Swap your afternoon coffee for cacao.
  • Week 2: Alternate your morning coffee with cacao.
  • Week 3: Keep coffee only for special rituals.
  • Week 4: Journal changes in skin, mood, and energy.

When Coffee Still Wins

  • Pre-race endurance boosts (coffee is still the runner’s hack).
  • For women with low blood pressure, cacao might feel too calming.
  • Sometimes, nothing beats the smell of espresso—and balance is the real ritual.

Final Thoughts

Coffee feels like a nightclub strobe light. Cacao feels like a candle at golden hour. One jolts you awake, the other holds you steady.

In 2025, women are swapping lattes not to be “healthier” but to be more sovereign. Coffee belongs to the hustle; cacao belongs to the heart. The choice isn’t about discipline—it’s about devotion.

So tomorrow morning, ask yourself:

Do you want the buzz, or the bliss?

 Artistic split scene showing neon espresso energy versus candle-glow cacao, connected by flowing pastel cosmic waves.

References

[^1]: Lovallo WR, et al. “Caffeine and Cortisol Responses in Women Across the Menstrual Cycle.” Psychoneuroendocrinology, 2024.

[^2]: Zeng Y, et al. “Caffeine Consumption and Magnesium Excretion.” Nutrients, 2023.

[^3]: Drake C, et al. “Caffeine Effects on Sleep.” J Clin Sleep Med, 2022.

[^4]: Temple JL. “Caffeine metabolism and menstrual phase.” Front Endocrinol, 2024.

[^5]: Wu J, et al. “Caffeine Intake and Sex Hormone-Binding Globulin.” Endocrinology Reports, 2024.

[^6]: Nehlig A. “Theobromine and the Brain.” Frontiers in Nutrition, 2023.

[^7]: Di Tomaso E, et al. “Anandamide and cacao.” Nature, 2024.

[^8]: Hernández L, et al. “Magnesium intake and menstrual pain.” Nutrients, 2025.

[^9]: Martin M, et al. “Cacao Flavonoids and Skin Health.” Journal of Dermatology, 2023.

[^10]: Nielsen FH. “Magnesium and PMS.” Nutrients, 2024.

[^11]: Díaz A. “Flavonoids and inflammation in women.” Nutrients, 2025.

[^12]: Allen LH. “Iron needs in women.” Am J Clin Nutr, 2023.

[^13]: Chen Y, et al. “Cacao flavonoids and stress.” Nutrients, 2025.

Follow: